Case Study in Reading Disorder: The Corrective Aspect of Craniosacral Fascial Therapy
Thursday, October 02, 2008
Dr. Barry R. Gillespie and Carol Newell
LITERATURE REVIEW
In 1899
William Sutherland D.O. found that the brain had a slight “breathing” motion, a
critical physiological factor for the function of the central nervous system.4
In 1976, Viola Frymann D.O. recommended osteopathic treatment in infancy
for the prevention of future learning disorders.5 In 1983 John
Upledger D.O. updated Sutherland’s work and taught the craniosacral concepts to
thousands of professionals worldwide.6 While trauma to this system
could cause a condition like reading disorder, treatment could restore normal
physiology and health to the child.7
The fascial
or connective tissue component of the craniosacral fascial system is a full
body web that intertwines and infuses with every structural cell including
nerves, muscles, blood and lymph vessels, organs, and bones.8 John
Barnes P.T. found that trauma strained the fascia leading to many symptoms and
conditions.8 These strain patterns can pull anywhere in the body,
including the brain, at up to 2,000 pounds per square inch.9
In
this craniosacral fascial system the nourishing cerebrospinal fluid begins its
journey in the choroid plexus of the ventricles, gently fluctuates through the
craniosacral system, and flows within the cranial and spinal nerve sheaths out
into the collagen tubules of the fascia.10 Researchers confirmed
this whole body system when they discovered cerebrospinal fluid in these
tubules with surprisingly no ordinary ground substance, blood, or lymph
present.11
THE GOAL OF
CRANIOSACRAL FASCIAL THERAPY
The goal of
therapy is to relieve the strain patterns around the brain causing the reading
disorder. Traumas to the craniosacral fascial system can occur anytime after
conception, most notably during a difficult birth. The brain cycle, the amount
of seconds the brain inherently moves in expansion and contraction, is the best
indicator to monitor how well this system is working.
Generally,
the longer the brain “breathes”, the better it can function. Craniosacral
fascial treatment over a series of visits can open a restricted brain with a
low cycle to normal brain motion to enhance the neurophysiology and improve the
reading skills of the child.
CASE PRESENTATION
History
On December 27, 2006 a
nine-year-old boy presented for evaluation for a reading disorder. He also had
severe asthma, some bouts of otitis media, seasonal mold allergies, and
occasional headaches. The pregnancy was uneventful until the 39th
week, when his mother had edema, headaches, and high blood pressure. Because
the fetus was in distress, her doctor induced her with oxytocin. After more
than six hours of difficult labor, the physician delivered him with the
assistance of a vacuum suction tube. As a result, he had a cone-shaped head
that lasted several weeks.
He was a
sickly child since he contracted asthma at two months of age. Taking many
asthma medications over the years, he did not “grow out” of it and consequently
missed a lot of days at school. He did not have any surgery or dentistry and
was up to date on all of his immunizations. He had the usual boy traumas but
had never been unconscious.
His first
grade teacher notified his parents of a reading problem. During class he
received extra one-on-one help to improve his skills. In the middle of second
grade he fell further behind even with classroom assistance, and the school
recommended a reading specialist to his parents. She began working with him in
January 2006 in the middle of second grade, about a year before therapy
started, and finished in August 2007 just before entering fourth grade, a few
months after therapy was completed.
Clinical Findings
His brain cycle was two seconds,
one second in expansion and one second in contraction; this indicated excessive
strain in his cranial dural meninges causing pressure around his brain. It was
not “breathing” freely, which would have allowed his cerebrospinal fluid to
fluctuate better throughout his central nervous system. His facial bones, dural
tube, and sacrum were abnormally tight, with no palpable motion.
The shape
of his head was asymmetrical with the large bones internally rotated on the
left side and externally rotated on the right side. His difficult birth
appeared to have caused this distortion. He had fascial strain, reflecting his
pediatric asthma condition, throughout his respiratory system from his sinuses,
nasopharynx, tracheobronchial tree, and down into his lungs.
I explained
to his mother that he had severe craniosacral fascial strain in his upper body.
Knowing that he primarily presented for his asthma, I explained to her that he
may also have a significant improvement with his other conditions including his
reading disorder. I outlined a series of one-hour treatment visits, and she
agreed to therapy.
Treatment and Results
The goal of therapy was to help
his body release his craniosacral fascial system. As his brain cycle opened up
over the visits, the fascia in his upper body released cleanly. Not only did
treatment help to loosen his respiratory tissue and improve his asthma, it
released pressure around his brain to improve his neurophysiology. Because of
the anatomy of the full-body web, fascial lung strain creating asthma was
pulling on the dural meninges of his brain, causing a reading disorder. One
soft tissue strain pattern causing multiple conditions is a different way to
look at the etiology of diseases.
Over the
course of five weeks he received seven one-hour treatment visits. His brain
cycle started at two seconds and ultimately opened to an acceptable one hundred
seconds. His facial bones, dural tube, and sacrum were all moving freely and in
synchronicity with his brain. His head was symmetrical and his fascia was
quiet. As a result, his medical doctor reported that his asthma was gone, and
his parents said that he no longer had earaches and headaches.
His reading
problem did not correct as quickly, but his schoolteacher saw a great
improvement by the end of third grade. His reading specialist applied the
Wilson Method, a program used by thousands of primary school teachers in the United States.
Before craniosacral fascial therapy, he scored a 42% in his total reading
ability. When she retested him after therapy, he increased this poor mark to an
excellent score of 94%. He became a confident reader, and consequently all of
his grades improved.
The reading
specialist also tested him in spelling with the Wilson Method. Before
craniosacral fascial therapy, his total spelling score without spell checker
was 19%. As an explanation, for every one hundred words that a child in his
grade should typically spell correctly, he was able to spell only nineteen
accurately. On retesting at the completion of therapy, he shot up to an 80%
score. This was a remarkable turnaround in such a short time.
His mother
noticed a profound change when craniosacral fascial therapy started in late
December to June, just before the end of the school year. Before therapy she
always had to sit with him for thirty to sixty minutes days before a spelling
test to keep going over and reinforcing the words. She also had to review all
of the words with him the morning of the test to keep them fresh in his mind.
After craniosacral fascial therapy, he studied for his spelling tests on his
own without any help from his mother and did well.
As a recent
update he had excellent grades upon finishing the fourth grade. His final
spelling grade was 92 and his reading grade was 87. Writing, math, social
studies, and science were all between 87 and 89. His mother said that watching
his confidence grow was the great reward from this experience. She knew he
always had the ability, but for some reason was not able to do the work.
DISCUSSION
Reading is a learned neurological function
that is important in our culture because it helps to grow the brain, develop
intelligence, and dictate a future career. If children present with a reading
disorder, craniosacral fascial therapy can be one effective tool for their
recovery. Not only can therapy be corrective for children with a reading disorder,
asthma, earaches, and headaches as in this case, it can also help children with
colic, ADHD, esophageal reflux, strabismus, rhinitis, and scoliosis.12, 13
Reading is a complex
skill that requires optimum function of many parts of the brain. The visual
cortex involves the sight, the pons tracks the words, the midbrain convergences
the eyes, and the vestibulococular nerve (XIII) hears the words. Important
landmarks are Broca’s area for processing vocabulary and grammar and Wernicke’s
area for language comprehension. As the child’s brain develops, the frontal
lobe can also enhance the meaning of words. If craniosacral fascial trauma
restricts the function of any of the above areas, the child’s reading can be
impaired.
In therapy
the opening of the brain cycle can jump-start the flow of cerebrospinal fluid
to improve the child’s brain function. The system normally contains four ounces
of fluid that is replaced every six hours; a healthy brain produces about one
pound of cerebrospinal fluid a day. This fluid needs to flow unimpeded
throughout the central nervous system to bring nourishment to and remove toxins
from the tissues of the brain and spinal cord.
An observer
may reason that his reading improvement was due to factors other than
craniosacral fascial therapy. The reading specialist was an experienced teacher
and enjoyed spending her retirement time helping children. The Wilson Program
had high marks as a learning tool from primary grade educators. As this child
aged, his cognitive mind may have matured more quickly. Only missing one day
this past year due to his asthma recovery, he also was at school more days,
which allowed him to spend more time on his reading and not be pressured to
catch up on his work.
Three
factors question this point of view. His mother followed his progress from week
to week like a hawk; moms know! Secondly, his change was so dramatic in such a
short period of time that it was unlikely due solely to these factors. Lastly,
I have seen similar results with countless other children, most having no extra
reading help, for thirty years. This case just had the documented testing to
quantify the positive results.
Since many
children may develop reading problems from the trauma of birth, professionals
need to check the craniosacral fascial system directly after the final APGAR
scores. If the newborn’s system is restricted, she/he can have therapy at the
beginning of life to help correct her/his neurophysiology. We also recommend
this approach at well care visits to help prevent reading disorders and other
illnesses in childhood.
SUMMARY
Craniosacral fascial therapy can
be an effective tool to help children with a reading disorder. This successful
approach merits a pilot study to evaluate its effectiveness.
REFERENCES
Medline
Plus Medical Encyclopedia, an online service of the United States National
Library of Medicine and the National Institutes of Health.
Tynan,
D. Learning Disorder: Reading.
Medicine from Web MD. eMedicine Specialties>Pediatrics>Developmental
and Behaviorial.
Rutter,
M. et al. Sex differences in developmental reading disability. JAMA. 2004; 291: 2007-2012.
Sutherland,
W. The Cranial Bowl. Mankato,
Minn: Free Press Company,
1939.
Frymann,
V. Learning difficulties of children viewed in the light of the
osteopathic concept. Journal of the
American Osteopathic Association 1976; 76: 734-738.
Upledger,
J., Vredevoogd, J. Craniosacral Therapy. Chicago: Eastland Press, 1983.
Magoun,
H. Osteopathy in the Cranial Field. 3rd edition. Kirksville, Mo:
Journal Printing Company, 1976.
Barnes,
J. Myofascial Release: The Search for Excellence. Paoli,
Pa: Rehabilatation Services T/A MyofascialReleaseTreatmentCenters and MFR
Seminars, 1990.
Katake,
K. The strength for tension and bursting of human fascia. Journal of KyotoProfessionalMedicalUniversity1961; 69: 484-488.
Juhan,
D. Job’s Body: A Handbook for Bodywork. Barrytown, New York12507: Station
Hill Press, 2003, page 73.
Kessel,
R., Kardon, R. Tissues and Organs: A Text-Atlas of Scanning Electron
Microscopy. San Francisco:
W. H. Freeman and Company, 1979, page 15.
Gillespie,
B. Healing Your Child. Philadelphia:
Productions for Children’s Healing, 1999.
Gillespie, B. Case study in pediatric asthma: the
corrective aspect of craniosacral fascial therapy. Explore: The Journal of Science and Healing. January 2008 Vol. 4,
Issue 1, pages 48-51.
The Family Hope Center
Toll-Free
1 (800) 888-9370 2490 Boulevard of the Generals, Suite 250, Norristown, PA 19403
local: (610) 397-1737 fax (610) 397-1880